That Night in Toronto

That Night in Toronto

Hawksley Workman's delicious wolves

Part 1 of the wonderfully wild Hearts on Fire interview

Michael Barclay's avatar
Michael Barclay
Nov 06, 2023
∙ Paid

Hawksley Workman plays the Danforth Music Hall this Thursday, November 9. Tickets here. His friend Murray Lightburn of the Dears is opening; I spoke to Murray about his latest solo record here.

Hawksley’s story is one of my favourite in Hearts on Fire. So much so that I dedicated an entire chapter to it: not because he’s more important than others, but because his trajectory is so indicative of that time and place: initial local indie success that flouts all conventions of the conservative Canadian music scene, then international acclaim, then Canadian radio singles, then a highly unlikely holiday record that becomes a perennial favourite (a real unicorn of a story, in my book or anywhere), a major label deal, and a quick crash and burn when blockbuster expectations aren’t met.

All in the space of about the six years the book focuses on.

Hawksley is also a great storyteller, very candid about his own accomplishments and failures. Artists could learn a lot from his story:

A lot of bands do this thing: they know they’ve been given keys to the machine that will give you access to the world. I was drinking enough wine at the time to not feel the true weight of that. I also knew there was an enormous amount of pressure on me to deliver something that people could sell. I had the kind of career where I was a phenom on stage: ‘Look at that guy! Look at him go!’

But my career was a litany of people around me saying, ‘But if you just did this; if you just adjusted this; if you were less like this and more like this.’ I listened to that for 10 or 12 years. It’s only been in very recent years where I’ve been satisfied to just be who I am. It took a fucking long time to get there.

Here’s a somewhat recent video, made by his friend Steve Bays from Hot Hot Heat, that features a lot of early footage, to give you a sense of how young Hawksley Workman presented himself.

Going to split this one into two parts, for length. Part one deals with his early days as a session drummer, his local songwriting heroes, just how weird the late ’90s were in Toronto, making records for $100 a song, stardom in France, and more.

For paid subscribers, this is the interview that fuelled the Hearts on Fire chapter “Don’t Be Crushed: The Cautionary Tale of Hawksley Workman.”

I’m noticing now that it was conducted two days into the first lockdown.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Michael Barclay.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Michael Barclay · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture